Truth

  PRAISE FOR PETER TEMPLE

  AND THE BROKEN SHORE

  WINNER

  Crime Writers’ Association Duncan Lawrie Dagger

  Ned Kelly Award for Best Novel

  Colin Roderick Award and H. T. Priestley Medal

  Australian General Fiction Book of the Year

  ‘The Broken Shore is one of those watershed books that makes you rethink your ideas about reading.’

  The Sydney Morning Herald

  ‘Peter Temple’s moody prose is far too satisfying…. The last thing you want is to see the mystery cleared up, the heroes and villains neatly sorted out…. Brilliant.’

  The Globe and Mail

  ‘One of the world’s finest crime writers.’

  The Times

  ‘Peter Temple can write, can make magic with words….

  The Broken Shore offers both poetry and gore, and it’s best if you have a taste for both.’

  The Washington Post

  ‘A stone classic.’

  The Independent

  ‘A compulsive read, which is too bad. It’s one of those books you can’t wait to finish and then can only regret that it’s ended.’

  New York Daily News

  ‘A towering achievement that brings alive a ferocious landscape and a motley assortment of clashing characters…. Indispensable.’

  The Guardian

  ‘Temple’s work is spare, deeply ironic; his wit, like the local beer, as cold as a dental anaesthetic.’

  The Australian

  ‘Utterly unforgiving…utterly convincing…. More please!’

  The Irish Times

  BY THE SAME AUTHOR

  An Iron Rose

  Shooting Star

  Identity Theory

  The Broken Shore

  The Jack Irish Novels

  Bad Debts

  Black Tide

  Dead Point

  White Dog

  Peter Temple’s bestselling novels are published in more than twenty countries. He has won the Ned Kelly Award for Crime Fiction five times. Truth is the sequel to The Broken Shore, winner of the world’s most prestigious prize for crime writing, the Duncan Lawrie Dagger. Peter Temple lives in Victoria.

  For Anita and for Nick: the lights on the hill.

  And for MH, whose faith has transcended reason.

  ‘But because truly, being here is so much; because everything here apparently needs us, this fleeting world, which in some strange way keeps calling to us. Us, the most fleeting of all.’

  Rainer Maria Rilke

  ON THE Westgate Bridge, behind them a flat in Altona, a dead woman, a girl really, dirty hair, dyed red, pale roots, she was stabbed too many times to count, stomach, chest, back, face. The child, male, two or three years old, his head was kicked. Blood everywhere. On the nylon carpet, it lay in pools, a chain of tacky black ponds.

  Villani looked at the city towers, wobbling, unstable in the sulphurous haze. He shouldn’t have come. There was no need. ‘This air-conditioner’s fucked,’ he said. ‘Second one this week.’

  ‘Never go over here without thinking,’ said Birkerts.

  ‘What?’

  ‘My grandad. On it.’

  One spring morning in 1970, the bridge’s half-built steel frame stood in the air, it crawled with men, unmarried men, men with wives, men with wives and children, men with children they did not know, men with nothing but the job and the hard, hard hangover and then Span 10–11 failed.

  One hundred and twelve metres of newly raised steel and concrete, two thousand tonnes.

  Men and machines, tools, lunchboxes, toilets, whole sheds—even, someone said, a small black dog, barking—all fell down the sky. In moments, thirty-five men were dead or dying, bodies broken, sunk in the foul grey crusted sludge of the Yarra’s bank. Diesel fuel lay everywhere. A fire broke out and, slowly, a filthy plume rose to mark the scene.

  ‘Dead?’ said Villani.

  ‘No, taking a shit, rode the dunny all the way down.’

  ‘Certainly passed on that shit-riding talent,’ said Villani, thinking about Singleton, who couldn’t keep his hands off the job either, couldn’t stay in the office. It was not something to admire in the head of Homicide.

  On the down ramp, Birkerts’ phone rang, it was on speaker.

  Finucane’s deep voice:

  ‘Boss. Boss, Altona, we’re at the husband’s brother’s place in Maidstone. He’s here, the hubby, in the garage. Hosepipe. Well, not a hosepipe, black plastic thing, y’know, like a pool hose?’

  ‘Excellent work,’ said Birkerts. ‘Could’ve been in Alice Springs by now. Tennant Creek.’

  Finucane coughed. ‘So, yeah, maybe the scientists can come on here, boss. Plus the truck.’

  ‘Sort that out, Fin. Might be pizza though.’

  ‘I’ll tell the wife hold the T-bones.’

  Birkerts ended the call.

  ‘Closed this Altona thing in an hour,’ he said. ‘That’s pretty neat for the clearance.’

  Villani heard Singo:

  Fuck the clearance rate. Worry about doing the job properly.

  Joe Cashin had thought he was doing the job properly and it took the jaws to open the car embedded in the fallen house. Diab was dead, Cashin was breathing but no hope, too much blood lost, too much broken and ruptured.

  Singleton only left the hospital to sit in his car, the old Falcon. He aged, grey stubble sprouted, his silken hair went greasy. After the surgery, when they told him Joe had some small chance and allowed him into the room, he took Joe’s slack hand, held it, kissed its knuckles. Then he stood, smoothed Joe’s hair, bent to kiss Joe’s forehead.

  Finucane was there, he was the witness, and he told Villani. They did not know that Singleton was capable of such emotions.

  The next time Cashin came out of hospital, the second time in three years, he was pale as a barked tree. Singo was dead by then, a second stroke, and Villani was acting boss of Homicide.

  ‘The clearance rate,’ Villani said. ‘A disappointment to me to hear you use the term.’

  His phone.

  Gavan Kiely, deputy head of Homicide, two months in the job.

  ‘We have a dead woman in the Prosilio building, that’s in Docklands,’ he said. ‘Paul Dove’s asked for assistance.’

  ‘Why?’

  ‘Out of his depth. I’m off to Auckland later but I can go.’

  ‘No,’ said Villani. ‘I bear this cross.’

  HE WENT down the passage into the bedroom, a bed big enough for four sleepers, mattress naked, pillows bare. Forensic had finished there. He picked up a pillow with his fingertips, sniffed it.

  Faintest smell of perfume. Deeper sniff. The other pillow. Different perfume, slightly stronger smell.

  He walked through the empty dressing-room into the bathroom, saw the glass bath and beside it a bronze arm rising from the floor, its hand offering a cake of soap.

  She was on the plastic bag in a yoga posture of rest—legs parted, palms up, scarlet toenails, long legs, sparse pubic hair, small breasts. His view was blocked by the shoulder of a kneeling forensic tech. Villani stepped sideways and saw her face, recoiled. For a terrible heart-jumping instant, he thought it was Lizzie, the resemblance was strong.

  He turned to the wall of glass, breathed out, his heart settled. The drab grey bay lay before him and, between the heads, a pinhead, a container ship. Gradually it would show its ponderous shape, a huge lolling flat-topped steel slug bleeding rust and oil and putrid waste.

  ‘Panic button,’ said Dove. He was wearing a navy suit, a white shirt and a dark tie, a neurosurgeon on his hospital rounds.

  Villani looked: rubber, dimpled like a golf ball, set in the wall between the shower and the head of the bath.

  ‘Nice shower,’ said Dove.

  A s
tainless-steel disc hung above a perforated square of metal. On a glass shelf, a dozen or more soap bars were displayed as if for sale.

  The forensic woman said, ‘Broken neck. Bath empty but she’s damp.’

  She was new on the job, Canadian, a mannish young woman, no make-up, tanned, crew cut.

  ‘How do you break your neck in the bath?’ said Villani.

  ‘It’s hard to do it yourself. Takes a lot to break a neck.’

  ‘Really?’

  She didn’t get his tone. ‘Absolutely. Takes force.’

  ‘What else?’ said Villani.

  ‘Nothing I can see now.’

  ‘The time? Inspired guess.’

  ‘Less than twenty-four or I have to go back to school.’

  ‘I’m sure they’ll be pleased to see you. Taken the water temperature into account?’

  ‘What?’

  Villani pointed. The small digital touchscreen at the door was set at 48 degrees.

  ‘Didn’t see that,’ she said. ‘I would have. In due course.’

  ‘No doubt.’

  Little smile. ‘Okay, Lance,’ she said. ‘Zip it.’

  Lance was a gaunt man, spade beard. He tried to zip the bag, it stuck below the woman’s breasts. He moved the slider back and forth, got it free, encased her in the plastic.

  Not ungently, they lifted the bag onto the trolley.

  When they were gone, Dove and Weber came to him.

  ‘Who owns this?’ said Villani.

  ‘They’re finding out,’ said Dove. ‘Apparently it’s complicated.’

  ‘They?’

  ‘The management. Waiting for us downstairs.’

  ‘You want me to do it?’ said Villani.

  Dove touched a cheekbone, unhappy. ‘That would be helpful, boss.’

  ‘You want to do it, Web?’ said Villani, rubbing it in to Dove.

  Weber was mid-thirties, looked twenty, an unmarried evangelical Christian. He came with plenty of country experience: mothers who drowned babies, sons who axed their mothers, access fathers who wasted the kids. But Old Testament murders in the rural welfare sumps didn’t prepare you for women dead in apartments with private lifts, glass baths, French soaps and three bottles of Moët in the fridge.

  ‘No, boss,’ he said.

  They walked on the plastic strip, passed through the apartment’s small pale marble hall, through the front door into a corridor. They waited for the lift.

  ‘What’s her name?’ Villani said.

  ‘They don’t know,’ said Dove. ‘Know nothing about her. There’s no ID.’

  ‘Neighbours?’

  ‘Aren’t any. Six apartments on this floor, all empty.’

  The lift came, they fell thirty floors. On the sixth, at a desk, three dark suits, two men and a woman, waited. The plump fiftyish man came forward, pushing back limp hair.

  ‘Alex Manton, building manager,’ he said.

  Dove said, ‘This is Inspector Villani, head of Homicide.’

  Manton offered his hand. It felt dry, chalky.

  ‘Let’s talk in the meeting space, inspector,’ Manton said.

  The room had a painting on the inner wall, vaguely marine, five metres by three at least, blue-grey smears, possibly applied with a mop. They sat at a long table with legs of chromed pipe.

  ‘Who owns the apartment?’ said Villani.

  ‘A company called Shollonel Pty Ltd, registered in Lebanon,’ said Manton. ‘As far as we know, it’s not occupied.’

  ‘You don’t know?’

  ‘Well, it’s not a given to know. People buy apartments to live in, investment, future use. They might not live in them at all, live in them for short or long periods. We ask people to register when they’re in residence. But you can’t force them.’

  ‘How was she found?’ said Villani.

  ‘Sylvia?’ said Manton. ‘Our head concierge, Sylvia Allegro.’

  The woman, dolly face. ‘The apartment’s front door wasn’t fully closed,’ she said. ‘The lock didn’t engage. That triggers a buzzer in the apartment. If it isn’t closed in two minutes, there’s a security alert and they ring the apartment. If that doesn’t work, they go up.’

  ‘So there in four, five minutes?’ said Villani.

  Sylvia looked at Manton, who was looking at the other man, fortyish, head like a glans.

  ‘Obviously not quite,’ said the man.

  ‘You are?’ said Villani.

  ‘David Condy, head of security for the apartments and the hotel.’ He was English.

  ‘What’s not quite mean?’

  ‘I’m told the whole electronic system failed its first big test last night. The casino opening. Orion. Four hundred guests.’

  ‘The open door. The system tells you when?’

  ‘It should do. But what with…’

  ‘That’s no?’

  ‘Yes. No.’

  ‘Panic buttons up there.’

  ‘In all the apartments.’

  ‘Not pressed?

  Condy ran a finger in his collar. ‘No evidence of that.’

  ‘You don’t know?’

  ‘It’s difficult to say. With the failure, we have no record.’

  ‘That’s not difficult,’ said Villani. ‘It’s impossible.’

  Manton held up a pudgy hand. ‘To cut to the whatever, inspector, a major IT malfunction. Coinciding with this matter, so we look a little silly.’

  Villani looked at the woman. ‘The bed’s stripped. How would you get rid of sheets and stuff?’

  ‘Get rid of?’

  ‘Dispose of.’

  The woman flicked at Manton. ‘Well, the garbage chute, I suppose,’ she said.

  ‘Can you tell where garbage has come from?’

  ‘No.’

  ‘Explain this building to me, Mr Manton. Just an outline.’

  Manton’s right hand consulted his hair. ‘From the top, four floors of penthouses. Then six floors, four apartments each. Beneath them, it’s fourteen floors of apartments, six to a floor. Then it’s the three recreation floors, pools, gyms, spas, and so on. Then twelve more floors of apartments, eight to a floor. Then the casino’s four floors, the hotel’s ten floors, two floors of catering, housekeeping. And these reception floors, that’s concierge, admin and security. The casino has its own security but its systems mesh with the building’s.’

  ‘Or don’t.’ Villani pointed down.

  ‘Under us, the business floors, retail, and hospitality, ground floor plaza. Five basement levels for parking and utilities.’

  In Villani’s line of sight, the door opened. A man came in, a woman followed, even height, suits, white shirts.

  ‘Crashing in,’ said the man, loud. ‘Introductions, please, Alex.’

  Manton stood. ‘Inspector Villani, this is Guy Ulyatt of Marscay Corporation.’

  Ulyatt was fat and pink, cornsilk hair, tuber nose. ‘Pleasure, inspector,’ he said. He didn’t offer a hand, sat down. The woman sat beside him.

  Villani said to Manton, ‘This person’s got something to tell us?’

  ‘Sorry, sorry,’ said Ulyatt. ‘I’m head of corporate affairs for Marscay.’

  ‘You have something to tell us?’ said Villani.

  ‘Making sure you’re getting maximum co-operation. No reflection on Alex, of course.’

  ‘Mr Manton is helping us,’ said Villani. ‘If you don’t have a contribution, thank you and goodbye.’

  ‘I beg your pardon?’ said Ulyatt. ‘I represent the building’s owners.’

  Silence in the big room. Villani looked at Dove. He wanted him to learn something from this. Dove held his eyes but there was no telling what he was learning.

  ‘We Own The Building,’ said Ulyatt, four distinct words.

  ‘What’s that got to do with me?’ said Villani.

  ‘We’d like to work with you. Minimise the impact on Prosilio and its people.’

  ‘Homicide, Mr Elliot,’ said Villani. ‘We’re from Homicide.’

  ‘It’s Ulyatt.�
�� He spelled it.

  ‘Yes,’ said Villani. ‘You might try talking to some other branch of the force. Impact minimisation division. I’m sure there’s one, I’d be the last to know.’

  Ulyatt smiled, a genial fish, a grouper. ‘Why don’t we settle down and sort this out? Julie?’

  The woman smiled. She had shoe-black hair, she’d been under the knife, knew the needle, the dermabrasion, detailed down to her tyres like a saleyard Mercedes.

  ‘Julie Sorenson, our key media person,’ said Ulyatt.

  ‘Hi,’ she said, vanilla teeth, eyes like a dead deer, ‘It’s Stephen, isn’t it?’

  ‘Hi and goodbye,’ said Villani. ‘Same to you, Mr Elliot. Lovely to meet you but we’re pushed here. A deceased person.’

  Ulyatt lost the fish look. ‘It’s Ulyatt. I’m trying to be helpful, inspector, and I’m being met by hostility. Why is that?’

  ‘This is what we need, Mr Manton,’ said Villani. ‘Ready?’

  ‘Sylvia?’ said Manton.

  She had her pen ready.

  ‘All CCTV tapes from 3pm yesterday, all lifts, parking,’ said Villani. ‘Also duty rosters, plus every single recorded coming and going, cars, people, deliveries, tradies, whatever.’

  Ulyatt whistled. ‘Tall order,’ he said. ‘We’ll need a lot more time.’

  ‘Got that down?’ said Villani to Sylvia Allegro.

  ‘Yes.’

  ‘Also the CVs and rosters of all staff with access to the thirty-sixth floor or who could allow anyone access. And the owners of apartments on the floor and other floors with access to the floor. Plus the guest list for the casino function.’

  ‘We don’t have that,’ said Ulyatt. ‘That’s Orion’s business.’

  ‘The casino function was in your building,’ said Villani. ‘I suggest you ask them. If they won’t co-operate, let Detective Dove here know.’

  Ulyatt was shaking his head.

  ‘We’ll show the victim on television tonight, ask for information,’ said Villani.

  ‘I can’t see the necessity at this stage,’ said Ulyatt.

  Villani delayed looking at him, met the eyes of Dove, Weber, Manton, Allegro, not Condy, he was looking away. Then he fixed Ulyatt. ‘All these rich people paying for full-on security, the panic buttons, the cameras,’ he said. ‘A woman murdered in your building, that’s a negative?’